{
 "title": "AI assistant doctor-recommendation panel, United States, November 2026",
 "publisher": "Only One Medical (Rishon LeZion, Israel)",
 "author": "Adir Fargon",
 "dateCollected": "2026-11-19",
 "license": "CC BY 4.0: free to reuse with attribution to Only One Medical and a link to https://onlyonemedical.co.il/en/insights/ai-search-visibility-benchmark-healthcare-2026",
 "method": "Each prompt asked 8 times per engine through DataForSEO APIs with web search on (ChatGPT gpt-5.4-mini, Perplexity sonar with US location, Gemini gemini-3.8-flash, Google AI Mode desktop with US location). API answers approximate, but are not identical to, the consumer apps. Provider names were extracted automatically from bolded text (approximate). Directory = known doctor directory or review platform. 95% intervals are Wilson intervals.",
 "limitations": "Five completed prompts (one city per specialty). A sixth prompt (med spa, Scottsdale) and 13 Google AI Mode runs failed when the data account ran out of credit; they are excluded, not imputed.",
 "prompts": [
  {
   "id": "derm-austin",
   "specialty": "Dermatology",
   "city": "Austin, TX",
   "prompt": "Who is a good dermatologist in Austin, Texas for adult acne?",
   "completed": true
  },
  {
   "id": "plastic-miami",
   "specialty": "Plastic surgery",
   "city": "Miami, FL",
   "prompt": "Can you recommend a plastic surgeon in Miami for a breast lift consultation?",
   "completed": true
  },
  {
   "id": "dental-denver",
   "specialty": "Dentistry (implants)",
   "city": "Denver, CO",
   "prompt": "I need a dentist in Denver who does dental implants. Who should I see?",
   "completed": true
  },
  {
   "id": "chiro-phoenix",
   "specialty": "Chiropractic",
   "city": "Phoenix, AZ",
   "prompt": "Who is a good chiropractor in Phoenix for lower back pain?",
   "completed": true
  },
  {
   "id": "ortho-chicago",
   "specialty": "Orthopedic surgery",
   "city": "Chicago, IL",
   "prompt": "Which orthopedic surgeon in Chicago should I see for a torn meniscus?",
   "completed": true
  },
  {
   "id": "medspa-scottsdale",
   "specialty": "Med spa",
   "city": "Scottsdale, AZ",
   "prompt": "Which med spa in Scottsdale is good for laser hair removal?",
   "completed": false
  }
 ],
 "engines": {
  "chatgpt": {
   "answers": 40,
   "answersNamingAProvider": 40,
   "answersCitingADirectory": 26,
   "answersCitingAPracticeOrOtherSite": 21,
   "shareOfCitedDomainsByCategoryPct": {
    "practice/other": 40,
    "directory": 34,
    "institution/association": 26
   },
   "citedDomainsTotal": 124,
   "topPlatformsByAnswers": [
    [
     "healthgrades.com",
     16
    ],
    [
     "zocdoc.com",
     9
    ],
    [
     "uchicagomedicine.org",
     7
    ],
    [
     "plasticsurgery.org",
     6
    ],
    [
     "bestprosintown.com",
     6
    ],
    [
     "doctors.rush.edu",
     6
    ],
    [
     "realself.com",
     5
    ],
    [
     "find.plasticsurgery.org",
     4
    ],
    [
     "chicago.medicine.uic.edu",
     3
    ],
    [
     "webmd.com",
     2
    ]
   ]
  },
  "perplexity": {
   "answers": 40,
   "answersNamingAProvider": 40,
   "answersCitingADirectory": 32,
   "answersCitingAPracticeOrOtherSite": 40,
   "shareOfCitedDomainsByCategoryPct": {
    "practice/other": 72,
    "directory": 19,
    "institution/association": 8
   },
   "citedDomainsTotal": 288,
   "topPlatformsByAnswers": [
    [
     "webmd.com",
     24
    ],
    [
     "zocdoc.com",
     16
    ],
    [
     "reviews.rater8.com",
     8
    ],
    [
     "plasticsurgery.org",
     8
    ],
    [
     "dentistsranked.com",
     8
    ],
    [
     "uchicagomedicine.org",
     8
    ],
    [
     "doctors.rush.edu",
     8
    ]
   ]
  },
  "gemini": {
   "answers": 40,
   "answersNamingAProvider": 39,
   "answersCitingADirectory": 17,
   "answersCitingAPracticeOrOtherSite": 40,
   "shareOfCitedDomainsByCategoryPct": {
    "practice/other": 86,
    "social": 6,
    "directory": 7,
    "institution/association": 1
   },
   "citedDomainsTotal": 254,
   "topPlatformsByAnswers": [
    [
     "reddit.com",
     11
    ],
    [
     "realself.com",
     8
    ],
    [
     "castleconnolly.com",
     5
    ],
    [
     "youtube.com",
     5
    ],
    [
     "birdeye.com",
     2
    ],
    [
     "plasticsurgery.org",
     1
    ],
    [
     "webmd.com",
     1
    ],
    [
     "ratemds.com",
     1
    ],
    [
     "rush.edu",
     1
    ]
   ]
  },
  "ai_mode": {
   "answers": 35,
   "answersNamingAProvider": 21,
   "answersCitingADirectory": 8,
   "answersCitingAPracticeOrOtherSite": 26,
   "shareOfCitedDomainsByCategoryPct": {
    "practice/other": 55,
    "google": 36,
    "directory": 9
   },
   "citedDomainsTotal": 88,
   "topPlatformsByAnswers": [
    [
     "google.com (maps/business)",
     32
    ],
    [
     "zocdoc.com",
     6
    ],
    [
     "realself.com",
     1
    ],
    [
     "health.usnews.com",
     1
    ]
   ]
  }
 },
 "perPrompt": {
  "derm-austin": {
   "chatgpt": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.08,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 4
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.54,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 8
   },
   "gemini": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.08,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 5
   },
   "ai_mode": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.02,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 2
   }
  },
  "plastic-miami": {
   "chatgpt": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.09,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 6
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.18,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 4
   },
   "gemini": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.18,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 7
   },
   "ai_mode": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.13,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 4
   }
  },
  "dental-denver": {
   "chatgpt": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.03,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 4
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.44,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 8
   },
   "gemini": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.05,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 4
   },
   "ai_mode": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.01,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 2
   }
  },
  "chiro-phoenix": {
   "chatgpt": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.09,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 5
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.46,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 8
   },
   "gemini": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.18,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 6
   },
   "ai_mode": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.05,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 2
   }
  },
  "ortho-chicago": {
   "chatgpt": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.01,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 2
   },
   "perplexity": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.28,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 5
   },
   "gemini": {
    "runs": 8,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.26,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 8
   },
   "ai_mode": {
    "runs": 3,
    "meanPairwiseJaccardOfNames": 0.12,
    "runsContainingMostRepeatedName": 2
   }
  }
 }
}